As Chicago's poorest face an increase to already-high public transit fees, the city is ignoring an offer of discounted diesel fuel to benefit low-income people.
Chicago, Dec 28 (TNS) - The Chicago Transit Authority is refusing an opportunity to alleviate commuting costs for hundreds of thousands in the Windy City's low-income neighborhoods. Instead of accepting deeply discounted fuel from the Venezuela-owned Citgo Petroleum Corporation, the city is instead raising fares to solve budget shortfalls.
In an October meeting with representatives from the Chicago Transit Authority (CTA), the city's Department of Energy and other city officials, Citgo unveiled a plan to provide the Chicago with low-cost diesel fuel. The company's stipulation, at the bidding of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez, was that the CTA, in turn, pass those savings on to poor residents in the form free or discounted fare cards.
But two months later, despite claims of a looming budget crisis, the CTA president "has no intent or plan to accept the offer," according to CTA spokesperson Ibis Antongiorgi. She gave no explanation.
According to Venezuela's consul general in Chicago, Martin Sanchez, the CTA has yet to inform his office of its decision to decline the discount offer.
In place of the proposed discount, which the CTA apparently does not want Chicagoans to even know about, budget shortfalls will be addressed by fair hikes. Chicagoans who are unaware of the Venezuela offer will be hit with an increase of 25 cents per ride next month, and discounted route-to-route transfers will be eliminated for passengers paying cash.
"This is going to hurt the poor and the minority people, like me," said Dorothy Chew, resident of Humboldt Park, where one-third of residents live below the federally recognized poverty level – currently just $16,000 for a family of three. Chew relies on the CTA to get to work and to Chicago Commons, where she attends classes daily in preparation for taking her GED. Since she rarely has money to invest in a fare card, she will be forced to pay for transfers the majority of the time.
Chew's classmate, Linda Cox, works a minimum-wage job and has been a Public Aid recipient for 15 years. She also relies heavily on public transportation.
"I only earn $560 a month and of that, over $200 a month goes to my bus fare," Cox told The NewStandard. "I have a 15-year-old and a 17-year-old who also need to get to school. If they change the prices and take away transfers, there are going to be a lot of days missed. I already see no money at the end of the month."
The offer of discount fuel is not just confined to Chicago. Over the Thanksgiving holiday, the first of Venezuela's "oil-for-the-poor" programs in the US was launched. Citgo struck a deal with three nonprofit organizations in the Bronx to deliver 5 million gallons of heating oil at 45 percent below the market price. The deal will amount to a savings of $4 million for the 8,000 low-income households slated to benefit from the plan.
Citgo has made a similar arrangement with Citizens Energy Corp. in Boston for the sale and distribution of 12 million gallons, saving low-income and elderly residents there a total of $10 million. The company's website says that it expects to expand the program to other boroughs in New York City and that it is exploring the possibility of offering discounted fuel to residents in Maine, Rhode Island, Connecticut and Pennsylvania.
However, in all of Illinois, only about 12,000 households use heating oil.
So instead of fuel for heat, Citgo representatives offered the CTA a 40-50 percent discount on diesel fuel for buses to benefit Chicagoans most in need of relief from soaring oil and gas prices this winter.
"We didn't know how else to reach enough people," said Consul Sanchez.
Another difference between the Chicago offer and the programs enacted in the Northeast is that Citgo proposed to work with a government agency, rather than nonprofit organizations. The CTA relies on the US federal government – which is in a constant war of words with Venezuelan President Chavez – for much of its funding. In fact, just weeks after Citgo made its offer to the CTA, Congress signed the Federal Transportation Appropriations bill, allocating $89 million in infrastructure project funds the CTA had been seeking for years.
Representatives from the US State Department and city officials, including Aldermen involved in the negotiations and the Chicago Mayor's Office, refused to respond to queries about whether international politics played any part in the CTA's rejection of Citgo's offer.
Some critics of President Chavez say his offer of cheap fuel to low-income communities in the US is a political ploy to win the support of the American people. Larry Birns, executive director of the progressive think tank, Council on Hemispheric Affairs, said Chavez is trying to counter Bush administration criticisms with "petro-diplomacy." Birns, who criticizes both US policy toward Venezuela and Chavez's confrontational style, told TNS, "There is a certain amount of humor involved in needling the Bush administration for neglecting it's own while attempting to stand tall in Latin America."
However, as Mark Weisbrot of the Center for Economic and Policy Research – another progressive think tank – pointed out, the Venezuelan government has been providing cheap fuel to several countries in Latin America. Weisbrot is a staunch supporter of the Chavez administration.
"It is part of [Venezuela's] policy to compensate for the impact of the high oil prices on poor people," he said. "They don't have any grudge against the American people; it's just the Bush administration that they don't like."
Consul Sanchez echoed this sentiment. "Any corporation that makes a big profit in a community owes that community something in return," he said. With one of Citgo's three light-oil refineries located in nearby Lemont, 30 minutes outside the city, Sanchez said, Venezuela has "a special relationship with people and community organizations in Chicago."
There remains no sign, however, that the government of Chicago will take Citgo and Venezuela up on the unilateral offer.
Comments
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
28 Dec 2005
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
28 Dec 2005
and what about discounted fare cards for... mmmwww... DISCRIMINATION! Chavez taking off his mask!
Contact the mass media
28 Dec 2005
ctc-TribLetter (at) Tribune.com
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
28 Dec 2005
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
29 Dec 2005
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
29 Dec 2005
How can you turn down cheap oil!
Let the people know & DO SOMETHING.
30 Dec 2005
That's how America works, after all. We'd rather be nationalistic and live on our knees to the ruling class (as long as they're American) than accept a gesture of solidarity from other working-class people (of any nation).
I recently read a long and detailed account of the CTA fare strike from last year, and the role that Midwest Unrest and other groups played in that.
Would it be possible for anyone to spread the word about this Venezuela thing directly to fellow CTA passengers, quickly? It doesn't cost all that much to print up some handbills with links to this page (or to the New Standard News page), and also info for how people can put pressure on the City (and their mainstream corporate media lapdogs) to cave in and take the Venezuelan oil.
Anyone want to organize? This is a golden opportunity!
Or is Chicago gonna just sit on its ass and make more excuses for corruption & privilege?
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
how about not being the troll who uses white working class people as the reason for every problem in the world. what do you think? there are no poor whites around here?
chicago is an incredibly racist town, there is no question, but to be such a creep that you'd try to blame working whites for mayor daley's political sickness is disgusting.
none of us are quite as stupid as to not see through that obvious troll tactic. i do recognize the fear that people like you have that poor people in the u.s. from all cultures will make political connections and agreements across cultural lines. i do recognize that the status quo is dependent on the cultural divisions that exist. i do know full well that people like you are talentless and gutless and need to maintain "racial" divisions in order to make sure you get yours.
i'm doing everything i can to see to it that you will get what's coming to you, trust me.
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
Where's Luis Guittierrez? Why not put some heat on him? What about Obama and Durbin? These are guys who are supposed to be so progressive, why can't they take a stand for the poor?
We EXPECT Mayor Daley to suck, that's a given, he is a nasty evil shill, and that's just how that always is. The only success we ever get against him is circumventing him. Trying to go directly to him is always fruitless. Why bother? So you can get ulcers?
How about Danny Davis, Bobby Rush, and as mentioned Guittierrez? These are the guys who represent a lot of the people who would benefit most from this situation.
When I worked out in the 'burbs I took Public Transit with dozens and dozens of people from the far south side, it was amazing. They'd be up at 4 am to get to a job that started at 7 am. You expect DALEY to give a s__t about them?
Of course Daley and all his sellouts like Ibis Antongiorgi are going to suck.
At this point, if we don't start manuevering around Daley, and finding ways to circumvent his position, we only have ourselves to blame for whatever happens, and also some of the other political leaders who use the pain he causes as political leverage, when they know damn well they can band against him and stop this sick situation in this town.
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
where is he.. where is that info?
is it the media gain? not reporting?
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
www.venezuelanalysis.com/news.php
www.venezuelanalysis.com/news.php
here are some links from around the world
but NO LINKS FROM CHICAGO LOCAL MAINSTREAM MEDIA!
what's up assholes! little sleepy today or is your boss threatening your jobS?!
we know you read these threads!
Gutierrez
30 Dec 2005
Gutierrez has easy access to the press, so whether he was a broker or not, why is he participating in the secrecy surrounding this deal?
Gutierrez needs to speak out NOW!
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
blaming daley for everything is just weak. all the secrecy and mystery means that no matter who the next mayor is it's going to be just more of the same inefficient, treacherous, ugly, moronic way of doing things.
if there is some mystery politician engineering things in the background, why can't they speak up? i don't think that is the kind of leadership i want to get behind.
we need some forthrightness around here. enough of this esoteria.
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
and who cares if they are hispanic? whomever the heck it is needs to step up to the plate and make some noise.
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
30 Dec 2005
They - and the aldermen who participated in the negotiations as well - haven't been given even the courtesy of a formal answer. Just the quote from the CTA's press hack when interviewed.
Why don't you call the CTA yourself and inquire about this - then post the results here.
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
04 Jan 2006
she's the best!
Lawmakers to CTA: Take The Fuel!
Bob Roberts Reporting
CHICAGO (WBBM) -- A trio of legislators have a warning for the CTA: think twice before bypassing an offer from Citgo Petroleum Corp. to provide it with cut- rate diesel fuel.
WBBM Newsradio 780's Bob Roberts reports CTA President Frank Kruesi indicated through a spokesperson last week that he would "bypass" the offer because he found it "inappropriate."
State Rep. Marlow Colvin (D-Chicago) said the CTA must be doing well if it can bypass an offer that would save it millions, and said CTA's attempts to get new funding sources may be derailed if Kruesi stands fast.
"Frank Kruesi, we're sending a warning to you today," he said. "When you come down with that hat, there'd better be a check for $15 million in it."
The CTA has said that Citgo is offering the wrong type of fuel, that accepting it could endanger existing contracts, and that Citgo's demand that it provide free farecards to poor riders as part of the deal would break state law.
Colvin and State Reps. Cynthia Soto and Larry McKeon (D- Chicago) said they will move to change the Metropolitan Transit Authority Act, that governs the CTA, if necessary, and said the
farecard and contract issues have NEVER come up in discussions on the offer.
They said Citgo has also assured them that it can supply the low- sulphur diesel fuel the CTA uses.
The legislators issued their warning during a raucous, hour-long news conference in Chicago's Loop during which aldermen, legislators and U.S. Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) criticized the CTA's position for a variety of reasons.
The CTA spokesperson told WBBM that Kruesi believed dealings with Citgo, which is owned by the Venezuelan government, would be "inappropriate" given the tensions between the Bush Administration and the government of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez.
Gutierrez cited a Dec. 8 State Department briefing in which it voiced no objections to Citgo's offers, made not just to the CTA but to a variety of agencies and housing groups in U.S. cities, as well as statements from the Energy Department endorsing the offers.
"If the people of Venezuela are ready to give this gift, a public gift, to the people of the city of Chicago," he asked, "who is Frank Kruesi to stand in the way?"
He then mockingly suggested that the City of Chicago shut down the hundreds of Citgo service stations if it's so concerned about Citgo and diplomacy.
"Obviously I say that in a rhetorical tone because everyone would say I'm loco," Gutierrez said.
Transit advocates also called on the CTA to accept the offer, and said they would demand at the Jan. 11 meeting of the CTA's board that it roll back the fare restructuring, which is intended to bring in $17 million in revenues to the CTA this year.
Kruesi planned a response at a 2:30 p.m. news conference.
Congressman and IL Lawmakers, urge Chicago to accept Venezuela's Discounted Diesel
05 Jan 2006
Venezuelan government officials and representatives from CITGO, a subsidiary of Venezuela's state oil company PDVSA, met with Chicago officials last October to offer diesel fuel at a 40% discount for the city public buses, on the condition that the savings are passed on to riders.
Two months after the offer, Chicago's Transit Authority, has not provided CITGO or Venezuelan government officials any feedback on the offer in spite of a transportation budget deficit of 17 million for fiscal year 2006 due to high fuel costs. Instead, as of January 1, 2006, bus fares paid in cash increased by 25 cents to 2 dollars, and transfer tickets now cost 2 dollars more if paid with cash.
It is unknown if the refusal to accept the offer comes from CTA Commissioner Frank Kruesi or from Mayor Richard Daley directly, but almost all of those who participated in the press conference, including State representatives Cynthia Soto, Marlow Colvin and Larry McKeon, blamed Kruesi.
CITGO's proposed a 40 percent discount on 7.2 million gallons of diesel fuel which could save the city approximately $15 million, according to a press release by Congressman Gutierrez.
The proposal to provide discounted oil products to poor communities in the U.S. was initially proposed by Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez, during his September visit to New York for a United Nations General Assembly meeting, weeks after hurricane Katrina left thousands of poor U.S. residents without assistance from U.S. federal and local authorities.
New York City and Massachusetts are already taking advantage of discounted CITGO heating oil for low-income families, and Maine, Vermont Rode Island, Delaware, Connecticut and Pennsylvania are currently in talks with CITGO and Venezuelan officials regarding similar offers.
"If other major cities are working with CITGO to reduce the strain of skyrocketing energy prices this winter, why is the CTA leaving Chicago out in the cold," added Gutierrez. "This proposal represents millions of dollars that can be used to help shore up the CTA's finances and to assist low-income riders. It is that simple."
"Instead of starting this New Year off with millions of dollars in savings on fuel expenses that could go toward helping the city's cash-strapped public transportation systems get its finances in order, the CTA has instead asked riders to bear the brunt of its poor fiscal management by raising cash fares and eliminating cash transfers," Gutierrez said.
"When we are repeatedly warned of doomsday scenarios, major service cuts and employee layoffs, how could the CTA outright reject an offer that could infuse millions of badly needed dollars into its operating budget. The public deserves an explanation," he added.
Alderman Billy Ocasio, who asked CITGO to offer diesel fuel to Chicago instead of the heating oil offered to other cities, said the CITGO proposal will ensure that the CTA remains an affordable option for those who need it most. "The CTA Board has repeatedly cried out for help and is in no position to turn down what amounts to $15 million in assistance; it must, therefore, reconsider CITGO's generous offer," Ocasio said.
CTA Commissioner Frank Kruesi later held a press conference arguing that CITGO's fuel would not work in CTA buses, and suggested CITGO could buy 15 million dollars in fare cards and distribute it them to Chicagoans. Kruesi also cited state laws, and CITGO's alleged demand that free fare cards are provided to poor riders, as reasons that would prevent Chicago from accepting the offer.
However, State Representatives at their press conference earlier, had said that state laws such as the Metropolitan Transit Authority Act, could be modified if it indeed prevents Chicago from buying cheaper diesel fuel for its buses. They said that fare card demands from CITGO and city contract issues have never come up in discussions on the offer.
Alderman Billy Ocasio said that the type of diesel is not an issue as CITGO has offered to obtain it from other companies in a procedure know as swap, in case it does not produce it in their Lemont, Illinois refinery.
A CTA spokesperson told the local Chicago WBBM radio station that Kruesi believed dealings with CITGO would be "inappropriate" given the tensions between the U.S. and the Venezuelan governments. Today Krusie said Chicago should not interfere in U.S. foreign policy. "We are not in the business of operating a separate foreign policy from the U.S. government, and I have no intention of beginning such a process," he said.
However, State Department spokesperson Adam Ereli provided no objections to the CITGO's offers at a Dec 8 briefing.
U.S. Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman also said that the U.S. government has no problems with Venezuela's offer. "We view it, as corporate philanthropy. We're all for that. Nobody in the Energy Department, or in the government for that matter, is going oppose that. If that's what Mr. Chavez and his colleagues who own CITGO choose to do, I'm certainly not going to criticize," Bodman told CNN last Dec. 9.
See also:
Chicago Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil
www.venezuelanalysis.com/news.php
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
05 Jan 2006
Re: CTA Turns Down Discounted Venezuelan Oil, Raises Fares Instead
05 Jan 2006
出会い
25 Mar 2008
shoes-luxury
04 Feb 2010
人生の値段チェッカー
08 Feb 2010
素人
08 Feb 2010