Chicago Indymedia : http://chicago.indymedia.org
Chicago Indymedia

LOCAL News :: Right Wing

report from minutemen protest

a synopsis of the days events...
Arlington Heights, IL:

At 8am on Saturday October 15, a diverse array anarchist, socialist, communist, and student groups gathered in opposition to a planned "Minutemen Bootcamp" at the christian liberty academy. With numbers swelling to nearly 60, the spontaneously organized protest began picketing outside of the church. As numbers of minutemen appearing increased, the crowd became more militant and decided to post itself in front of the building's main entrance. A short rally ensued, followed by a dance/drum circle at about 9am. The minutemen gathered on the porch decided to go inside for their planned activities.

At this point the 6 present Arlington Heights police were very hands off, only adding commentary asking the group to keep moving. The drum circle emboldened people, and a blockade was created in order to prevent late stragglers from entering. The police were able to force their way through the original blockade to let 2 stragglers in, but after this more joined and the minutemen security decided to start hopping railings instead of trying to get past the now 2-deep, 30 strong blockade.

Police then attempted to arrest a number of those blockading the entrance, however the crowd successfully unarrested everybody and the police left, upset at their own powerlessness. The crowd became emboldened, chanting "Un pueblo, unido, hamas eran vencido!" At this time the Coalition for African, Asian, Latino, and European Immigrants of Illinois arrived with 4 busloads of community members from all over chicago.

The blockade broke up to show solidarity and attend the planned rally with CAAELI. However, police reinforcements arrived and attempted to snatch a number of those from the crowd who had earlier participated in the blockade. They succeeded in 3 arrests, however the crowd fiercely fought back. This prompted a large riot squad to be called in, and the area surrounding the christian liberty academy to be flooded with police blockades. Police were singling out those who were earlier involved with the blockade as they left for their cars.

Organizers of the CAAELI rally denounced the earlier protest and refused to allow an announcement for jail support over their PA. Accusations flew of the "white left" being uninterested in showing solidarity with at risk communities. At one point an organizer said "you anarchist people should just go across the street and get yourself arrested, you obviously want to." This was despite the earlier blockade and unarrests were very diverse, both in color and political viewpoints.

The police presence and the snipers atop the christian liberty academy added to the tensions, and helped create a divide between those willing to put their bodies on the line and those who cannnot risk being deported. In reality, there was an amazing amount of solidarity from the rank and file of both contingents. Families shouted down minutemen and cheered when a car whose bumper bore a confederate flag's tires were flattened. Radicals attended the rally and heard out the planned speakers, choosing to end militant action in respect of the presence of higher risk people and the increased police force.

All in all there were 5 arrests, and the protest dispersed very early because of tensions created by the police.

pictures at:

chicago.indymedia.org/newswire/display/64231/index.php
 
 

Add a new comment
Title
Author
  Create a new account
Text Format

Comment

Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.

Comments

Re: report from minutemen protest

The blockade of the side entrance did not, unfortunately, receive total support from all the protesters in that spot. The PLP (Progressive Labor Party), for instance, were too busy standing on the sidelines chanting monotonously for "Communist Revolution" to help out by linking arms. One of them actually pulled back a comrade of his who was getting too close to the action, telling him he was needed elsewhere. I left before noon, however, so it's possible they might have helped out later.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

nice reporting. grasías
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

You all are asshats, why the hell would you show up JUST to cause trouble? Shows how a feeble mind works.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

No one showed up just to cause trouble. In fact, it's correct to confront racists at every turn, in every situation. The folks from caaelii had no problem with that. And the folks from caaelii also believe that, for most of the day, there was, as galleani reported, “an amazing amount of solidarity from the rank and file of both contingents.”

And the folks from caaelii never denounced the earlier protests, the blocking of the entrances, or the “unarrests.” Whoever claims that is absolutely wrong. The problem we had was with the arrests that happened in the middle of the march, in the middle of a mass of immigrant women, men, and children (arrests that, we acknowledge, may not have been provoked), and, even more upsetting, the assumption that the immigrants we were with (some undocumented, many seniors and children) were somehow expected to provide jail support.

In fact, the people who attended the mass rally (organized by caaelii and arriving in buses from all across the city) had no idea that "advanced actions" were planned, or that these "advanced actions" had actually happened before they got there. Their understanding was that they were going to march and rally and hear a message directed toward the racist minutemen and the local congressman, Kirk. They also wanted to know what they could do about the minutemen and Kirk’s silence on the matter. And there was a specific program and set of speakers to put that message out. That’s what those that are criticizing caaelii do not understand.

And if you, whom are critiquing caaelii today, would have stood with the immigrants at our rally, you would've known that we did mention the actions of the police. And criticized those actions.

And you also would've known that it wasn't you who were being asked if "everything was okay," or if "the police were going to arrest us all." Caaelii's organizers had to answer those questions, not you all. And caaelii's organizers are gonna have to answer those questions again, the next time we call for a rally or march.

We will talk to these bases of ours about the police presence, what it represents, and what our response to it will be in the future. We will also talk to them about building a movement, and building more support and alliances with other, non-immigrant groups like yours.

As opposed to the way some others organize--by only propagandizing, criticizing “reformers,” and acting as if they were the only militants around. Some from the p.l.p. even had the nerve to call the young people wearing Puerto Rican flags as capes “reactionary.” And some from the r.c.p. called a caaelii organizer an “asshole.”

That is what happened on Saturday.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

You are right, no one here is defending the PLP , The PLP calls for a "violent communist revolution" yet they stood bye doing nothing as police assaulted people... The issue between friends of those arrested and Caaelii was that the more "militant" people asked caaelii organizers to use the pa to announce jail support and ask if people would donate bail money... thats it. and the refusal of caaelii to do so seem like a slap in the face of those who were arrested and harrassed by cops. Caaelii let down the very people who were their fighting for their right to live freely.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

Hate'em - or anyone, really - provide proof that the Minutemen organization is "racist." Do so, or shut up. Your protests can legitimately go no further without this proof.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

Um,

Are you asking a left-wing lunatic for evidence to back up a statement? LOL!
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

the person calling her/himself "witness" reports that "the more 'militant' people asked caaelii organizers to use the pa to announce jail support and ask if people would donate bail money... thats it." well, that's untrue, because i was the one who was asked for the pa by the more "militant" person, and she never said what you claim she said. if she says that she did, then she's not telling the truth either.

as for caaelii letting down "the people who were fighting for their right to live freely," thank you for the patronage. and maybe look at that sentence again and see if it's got any elements of "white privilege" in it.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

Interesting...I was there, and some caaelii people were definitely race-baiting (as this last comment does as well--guess what, not everyone involved in a "left group" is white), cursing at them, telling them to leave and go "hold their own demo" and telling people not to donate money to help with jail for the people the police targeted (which included an arab women whose head scarf was ripped off by cops).

Thing is, other groups were organizing for this protest too before caaelii ever signed on--if caaelii organizers wanted to control things and wanted to have things go their way, then why didn't they ever talk to any of the other groups? All it would have taken was a phone call and maybe a meeting to say, Hey: we want no arrests or police confrontations, and Hey, we're planning on blockading the entrance/exit at this time...maybe undocumented folks should stay martching on the street and out of the path of cops, etc.

A little planning and communication could have gone a long way to diffusing tensions among groups.

Final thing: despite the assertion that *some* (not all!) caaelii folks put forward later that it was "white anrachists/leftists deliberatly provoking the cops", several actually were involved in trying to get kids and people out of the crowd when the cops moved in.

It's unfortunate that some people are buying into the divisions the cops are trying to sow among us. Any arrests, violence, etc. was the fault of the police and the racists--not activists who were there.
 

Minutemen are racist

because they seek to prevent persons they call "illegals" from entering lands stolen from their Mexican ancestors in the 1840s. This was in a war denounced by Illinois Congressman Abraham Lincoln, and later by former president US Grant who called it, "US aggression, pure and simple." If it was aggression then, why is it OK to ban the ancestors of the victims of that aggression from coming back to their lands?

Minutemen are racist because they attend a meeting called, "America First." This sort of excludes folk who are black and brown or yellow. Not to mention the Natives, from whom the lands were stolen in the first instance. They were called "savages" and "red skins." They were enslaved and killed. No racism there either, I suppose.

The Minutemen are racist because they say that "illegals" might also be "terrorists." Was there an effort to ban white people from Oklahoma City when Tim McVeigh wasted the federal building there?

Playing upon people's fears then blaming Arabs, "illegals," Japs, Niggers and Kikes for the alleged danger is as American as apple pie and that Old Tyme Religion. Its good 'ole American racism.

Meanwhile, the Cheney's and the billionaire exploiters they represent smirk and shake their heads in amazement that the old divide and conquer methods still work so damn well.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

Please stop distorting the truth and in some cases spreading outright lies.

Someone from CAAELI was in communication with the suburbanites who were organizing for this thing and it was communicated that immigrants and their families, which also included undocumented persons, would be arriving at 11am. I personally telephoned one of the main suburban organizers in the days preceeding the protest to explain the very same thing and was assured that they were planning a completely green (ie. unarrestable) action and that it would be a safe space for these at-risk communities. The blockade was a spontaneous (ie. unplanned) action by the way and while I blame the cops for the arrests those who participated in and/or witnessed the blockade should try to understand the situation that the vast majority of protesters were in rather than spout off reactionary nonesense like the person that I'm replying to.

It doesn't matter who was organizing for this thing first. No one can claim ownership of these actions regardless of how much or how long they organized for it. No one from CAAELI, which brought out 2/3 of the people there, tried to control anything other than their own pre-planned rally and that was within their right to do so. Truth is that there was a lot of confusion as to what was happening and what had gone down earlier in the day and this resulted in some tensions to be sure but the kind of attitudes and lies coming from people like the idiot above made things worse on the day of the protest and now only serve to exacerbate further those tensions and distort the truth of what actually happened.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

Dear another point of view,

By the way, just like not everyone involved in a left group is white, which I acknowledge, not all women who wear head scarves are Arab. In fact, this woman that you’re talking about, the one who got arrested, is South Asian, not Arab. But we all probably look alike to you.

There is nothing in my report that claims that caaelii folks wanted to “control things.” If you had read my post clearly, you would’ve realized that the very first thing I said was that I support confronting racists at every turn. And if you had been at the rally and heard what caaelii folks had said very clearly, on the microphone, you would know that we also placed the blame for the arrests and violence on the cops, not on the anarchists or anyone else.

Planning and communication could’ve been better, I agree, and since you all were organizing for this protest “before caaelii ever signed on,” I guess the onus should’ve been only on us to try and communicate with you, even though your folks knew that caaelii was bringing immigrants from all across the city. And we probably should have just kept all the Mexican and Cambodian and Korean and Chilean and South Asian and Arab and other immigrants, along with our black and white allies, at home.

Oh, one last thing, by the way. I have it on pretty good authority, from someone who is a very, very close ally to the anarchists who decided, with others, to blockade the entrance to the church, that this “advanced action” was totally spontaneous. Which is fine, again, but please know that “advanced actions” are gonna get some kind of police response, and if you tell people that the action is “green” and it ends up not being “green,” remember that there may be others there that are more at-risk than you. That’s the bottom line, and it would be nice if one of you would acknowledge that in the same way that we at caaelii have acknowledged that WE DON’T BLAME YOU FOR THE ARRESTS. But we do blame you for the arrogance of not understanding why some, maybe most, of the immigrants at the rally were frightened, confused, and upset.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

So I was hanging around the scene just after the first arrests and witnessed some caaelii members visibly shaken and wanting to confront police and offer support. To my chagrin, I noticed caaelii organizers take a no compromise stance and demand their folks keep marching and not ask questions. Have these concerned been raised in caaelii? I felt like caaelii organizers really had no grasp of situation and instead of moving with the flow of things demanded obedience. It was nerve racking. I understand some people didn't want to be arrested and wanted to remain safe. But for those that wanted to aid others, why weren't they given that kind of leeway? I'm just trying to understand caaelii dynamics i suppose.

Curious.
 

Re: report from minutemen protest

Um,

Are you asking a left-wing lunatic for evidence to back up a statement? LOL!
 
Donate

Views

Account Login

Media Centers

 

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software