LOCAL News :: Protest Activity
PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
reportback.








Over forty local activists, most from local indigenous communities, protested the city's Columbus Day Parade October 10th. One among them, known to many as Scribbler, was detained by police and taken to the first district station.
While Midwestern high school marching bands and corporate television floats promoted Columbus Day as the city's main day to celebrate Italian heritage, indigenous activists resisted through their cultural traditions using dance and ceremony, and others carried out a die-in, talked with spectators, and chanted along the route. A small group met at Columbus and Jackson, while more met up later at Buckingham Fountain.
About half a dozen activists marched near Mayor Daley for about half of the parade route, jeering him and causing a visibly upset Daley to make a quicker move to exit the parade and return to City Hall. The police quickly surrounded and handcuffed Scribbler, detaining him for swearing after goading a spectator into offering to be a witness. He was taken down to the 1st District under Commander Keating who was on the scene, although he was not processed and only given a citation. He will have a courtdate December 1st at the courts on the 400 block of Superior St.
Meanwhile, the reception activists got from the celebrants of genocide was mixed. Many, including onlookers and even people in floats agreed with the protesters on their main points, some offering not to celebrate in future years. Others hurrahed genocide, swore at activists, and one protester was even shoved.
Columbus was one of the perpetrator's of a genocide that cost at some 80-100 million lives of indigenous peoples throughout the Americas, not to mention later causing the Atlantic Slave Trade which compounded that number. In Chicago, as in other cities, his holiday has been taken up by Italian-American communities as the day to celebrate their heritage, while in some countries like Venezuela they celebrate Indigenous Resistance Day instead. Protesters contended that there are many other days and heroes of Italian history that make better sense than a genocidal imperialist that died of syphilis believing he had gone to India.
Last year, after hundreds protested in Colorado and blocked a Columbus Day Parade, 350 were arrested, including Ward Churchill who is coming to speak at DePaul (see that post on the center panel). After a closing ceremonial event that thanked ancestors and the Mexica Creator for the survival of culture, protesters at the parade today vowed to make it an annual event, hoping to bring hundreds next year. Some indigenous activists joked that they might meet again for the Thanksgiving Day Parade, and many planned to attend the protest against the Project Minuteman conference on October 15th (in one photo an activist can be seen passing out flyers)
quoted from today's Chicago Tribune:
But not everyone found a reason to celebrate Columbus Day.
"Columbus didn't do anything but massacre natives of Puerto Rico, Cuba and Dominican Republic," said Sandra Sosa of Chicago, who was protesting the day. "It's not a problem with the Italian community, but with the celebration of this individual."
Sosa was among nearly two dozen protesters who staked out a spot in front of Buckingham Fountain and across from the parade's reviewing stand.
Comments
Re: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
10 Oct 2005
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
Nonsense. The real culprits were the "Conquistadores" like Pizarro, Cortez, De Almagro, etc. Columbus just ran into the Americas because he was looking for Asia. The Americas were bound to be invaded and colonized by European armies and settlers due to their technological and military advantage. The fact that this Italian explorer landed on Guanahani on October 12, 1492 is absolutely irrelevant.
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
so, are you saying that Colon (aka Columbus) didnt have the hands or feet chopped off of the arawaks/tainos who didnt bring him enough gold from their slavery in the mines? or that he didn't force tribute from all males over the age of 14, taking others to sell in the slave market back in España? what of his command that his men round up entire villages often to have them slaughtered in retaliation for resistance? or of the burnings or hangings of many arawaks/tainos, while others had their noses cut off, many of these tactics already used by the Spaniards against the Moors and others during the inquisition? or that Columbus used famine and disease to exacerbate the extermination, the genocide? during the first six years Columbus was governor of the island of Hispaniola, where the extermination of three to seven million took only a few decades.
read fernando columbus or bernardo de las casas for ealry depictions of the conquest. then tell me if columbus was irrelevant.
and answer this simple question in your response next time: do you believe Columbus Day is a legitimate holiday, or a myth used to cover up history and celebrate genocide?
i pity the fool.
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
It was the year 1492 for crying out loud. The crimes committed by Columbus (Colon is the Spanish version of his name) were the norm back then. In fact, the Aztecs and Inkas treated conquered tribes even worse. And don't get me even started by the way the Moors treated Christians (does the term dhimmi say something to you?).
Regarding your question if Columbus Day is a legitimate day. It's just a frivolous holiday where Italian-Americans can celebrate their "Italianess". And protesting it is - quite frankly - extremely pathetic.
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Oct 2005
It was the year 1492 for crying out loud. The crimes committed by Columbus (Colon is the Spanish version of his name) were the norm back then. In fact, the Aztecs and Inkas treated conquered tribes even worse. And don't get me even started by the way the Moors treated Christians (does the term dhimmi say something to you?).
Regarding your question if Columbus Day is a legitimate day. It's just a frivolous holiday where Italian-Americans can celebrate their "Italianess". And protesting it is - quite frankly - extremely pathetic.
kurt such a troll he belong under a bridge
11 Oct 2005
lets stay specific. dhimma law was a sometimes humiliating and often discriminatory practice that the Moors and some other Islamic political systems enforced over non-Muslims, but at its core, it was about paternalism and limited tolerance, and included far more rights for the minority religions than christians carried out in the same period. the Moors were conquerors, something that us Anti-Imperialists are against, but they were far more honorable than most all European conquerors of their time. the spanish inquisition, on the other hand, was the christian genocide that forced Muslims and Jews to convert or die and was used against political dissidents as well, leaving between 30,000 and 135,000 dead. that was what the Spanish did to their own people.
and the Mexicas/Nahuas/Aztecs were not known to genocidally eliminate entire civilizations. ruthless, yes. conquerors, yes. but they were no where near on the scale of the European savages. and most nations/tribes that fell to the Inca actually did so peacefully. again, both were conquerors, but much more civil than the cruel white demons of Imperialist Europe.
and 'for crying out loud,' the 'it was 1492...it was the norm back then' defense is the stupidist, most incompetent AND ignorant irrational argument you could have possibly made. thats just stupid. people didnt somehow evolve morals and ethics since then. there were white europeans and many others around the world who were horrified at what was going on. what a simply stupid statement. so you excuse the African slave trade with that defense? roman crucifixion of christ was 2000 years ago, lynchings were back in the early 1900s, the nazi genocides were way back in the 1930s and 1940s. so lets just excuse every crime in history (and today) bcuz thats 'just what people did.'
finally, in response to your last two parts (i really do enjoy this, it forces us to think and articulate): first, if we should just respect Italian Americans right to celebrate on Columbus Day, then we should support German Americans right to celebrate on Hitler's Birthday. italy, a country we are taught extensively about in this country's farce of a school system, had many great heroes that were actually worth celebrating: garibaldi, tesca, malatesta, gramsci, spartacus (tho he wasnt actually italian).
and that protesting it is 'pathetic.' well, ill leave that up to the readers. but a man that created the carnage he is responsible for, that is an insult to celebrate him. altho perhaps it is very appropriate to do so in a country/Empire like the United States.
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
12 Oct 2005
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
11 Nov 2005
Do you count the GENOCIDE of people by other warring tribes having no contact with Columbus. Of course not.
Columbus killed: 0 people
Savages killed: 115 million
I guess your cause is totally bogus (again)
Re: PHOTO UPDATE: Activists Protest Columbus Day Parade
12 Nov 2005
"MAN I DON'T CARE!"
But I realize that some people are professional protesters....that their lives would not have meaning without something to protest....so I shouldn't expect any different....
出会い
25 Mar 2008