500 students, parents, teachers, and community members packed into the auditorium of Senn High School on Tuesday night for what was billed as a “Community Forum” about Chicago Public Schools’s plan to turn part of Senn into a naval academy. Opposition to the plan was so vocal, however, that the military representatives were unable to present their program.
It was a presentation turned into a protest with the trappings of a pep rally. Over 500 students, parents, teachers, and community members packed into the auditorium of Senn High School on Tuesday night for what was billed as a “Community Forum” about Chicago Public Schools’s plan to turn part of Senn into a naval academy run by the Junior ROTC. But the CPS and JROTC presenters weren’t able to give their presentation over the chants of “WE SAY NO!”, nor were they able to show their video to the audience’s turned backs. School and community organizers transformed the event into a real town hall meeting with an open mic, but the CPS and ROTC officials did not stick around to hear what the community had to say.
The evening began at 6 pm, when Save Senn Coalition members gathered outside the high school , located at 5900 N. Glenwood Ave., to greet people as they came and distribute informational pamphlets about Senn High School and the fight to keep it free of a naval academy. Other members, many of them students, circulated with a petition in support of the Save Senn Coalition goals. Area peace activists handed out flyers of “Questions the Military Doesn’t Want You to Ask,” and Andersonville Neighbors for Peace were there to, as their flyer read, “stand with everyone who opposes turning Senn High School into a military training school.” Matt Johnson and Matt O’Donnell sat on a bench with a “Books Not Bombs” sign. Both students at Loyola University, they’d heard about the forum via e-mails sent out through campus listservs. “I’m opposed to the military, period,” said Johnson. “I’ve been trying to get some counter-recruitment organized on campus, and then I heard about this.” O’Donnell explained that he came to learn more about the issues facing the school, “especially the military going into low-income schools and making promises that won’t be fulfilled.”
Inside, there were tables with official Senn publications. According to one flyer, Senn students come from 70 different countries, with 43.4% of students born outside the US. 64.6% of Senn students speak a language other than English at home, for a total of 57 languages school-wide. Senn’s newsletter noted that at a recent meeting for parents of bilingual students, translation was provided in Spanish, Urdu French, Vietnamese, and Gujarati. Attendants were also asked to sign in, though it was unclear for what purpose and under whose auspices.
A little before the announced starting time of 6:30, the official program started. People were still streaming into the auditorium. Students, many of them dressed in Senn colors, lined the aisles with posters in English, Spanish, and (I’m pretty sure) Arabic declaring “SAVE SENN! NO NAVY! AND SENN IS OUR HOME—PLEASE DON’T DIVIDE IT!” According to the agenda I received when I entered the auditorium, I’d just missed welcoming remarks from Senn Principal Judith Hernandez and Alderman Mary Ann Smith. Smith has been one of the naval academy’s chief advocates. “I think they basically offer an option. A different kind of discipline, a different kind of camaraderie, a look at a slightly different kind of world,” Smith said in a story posted early Tuesday evening at CBS2Chicago.com.
After Smith’s remarks, David Pickens, Deputy CEO of Chicago Public Schools told the crowd that the presentation that evening would “dispell misinformation” and “let people know about all the great things the naval academy has to offer.” His comments were met with boos from the audience, although they were nothing compared to what was to come. Principal Hernandez asked students to give the presenters a fair hearing, and Pickens repeated several times that the academy would not have any impact on the school. Instead, it would be a small academy, like the one at Bronzeville on the South Side. At CPS, he said, “We like the high attendance rates, low drop-out rates, and purpose—‘to build citizenship, teamwork, and discipline’” that such military academies offered.
According to the agenda, the introductions were to be follwed by an “Overview of the Proposed Educational Program” for the military academy, given by Colonel Rick Mills. Mills, who was accompanied by four or five other military representatives in civilian suits, had barely started speaking when the audience began to boo and chant “WE SAY NO!”
The chants kept up, and continued, as Mills repeatedly tried to get the audience’s attention. Many of them were now standing, some standing on their seats, and when Mills attempted to show the video, they turned their backs to him and to the screen.
The plan to start the naval academy at Senn was announced over the summer when school was not in session, but most Senn students, parents, and faculty didn’t hear about it until mid-September, when CPS surveyors showed up at the school. According to the Senn-Times, the academy is “backed by a a $2.1 million grant, and the ties shared by Chicago Public Schools and the Naval Service Training Command in Great Lakes, Illinois.” The naval academy, currently slated to open in fall 2005, will occupy the 29 classrooms that currently make up Senn’s freshman wing. It will be separated by a wall from the rest of the high school and function independently. CPS, according to its Renaissance 2010 plan, is trying to solve what it sees as the problems of under-utilization of buildings, lack of high school options, over-crowding and low performance in the Chicago schools by closing failing schools and reopening them as private charter and contract academies. Opponents, however, note that the schools CPS plans to close are largely in minority neighborhoods. As the most diverse school in Chicago, Senn would be a likely target. But Senn is hardly a failing school. In 2003, 83% of graduating seniors were planning to attend two or four year colleges. Senn has won a National Service Learning Leadership Award from the President of the United States, and it boasts, among other things, a multi-lingual/TESOL program, an Achievement Academy for 8th graders who have not yet met the requirements for high school, and a $1.2 million grant for “demonstrated leadership” from the Fry Foundation.
The pandemonium in the school auditorium continued. At last history teacher Jesse Sharkey got hold of the microphone. “It seems like people don’t want to watch the video,” he said. “I’m proposing that we have a discussion and some time for questions. “We do not believe this is a harmless plan, and we would like to have some community input, and perhaps some of us who have been following this closely could answer some questions.” Audience members began to line up and speak at an open mic, and someone volunteered to translate comments into Spanish.
“They’re taking the best third of Senn School away from Senn students,” said one woman. “Fairness requires that we give students what they need. The naval academy takes away a lot of what students need.” One speaker, who identified himself as a teacher at Senn, noted that opposition “goes much deeper than the militarization of the school. Our special education courses are already over the limits. We have a full 7th period lunc. Does that sound like a school that’s being underutilized?” Another speaker said that Senn is a model for other schools in the city. “Given that Senn operates so well, we have to question the motives of those who come here to change it. I think it’s time that CPS stop aiding the military.”
Alderman Smith, Deputy CEO Pickens, and Colonel Mills and his colleagues, however, seemed uninterested in such a format, and as audience members continued lining up for the open mic, they filed out a side entrance.
The open mic went on for about another hour, at which point Sharkey thanked supporters for coming out but asked that the gathering now disband so that the security guards could go home and the custodians could finish their work. He welcomed everyone to join the efforts of the Save Senn Coalition, noting that updates would be posted at
www.savesenn.org.
Comments
Mary Ann Smith Needs to Hear Our Message
07 Oct 2004
Smith needs to learn that she will pay a high price for her chosen avocation of "Navy junkie."
“I think they basically offer an option. A different kind of discipline, a different kind of camaraderie, a look at a slightly different kind of world,” Smith said.
What Smith calls "a slightly different kind of world," leads to the killing fields of Iraq. It leads to working class youth being Shanghaied to fight for the rich, for Haliburton and Bechtel. This is the function of the "discipline and camaraderie" of the Navy: training for killing for the profiteers.
This posture is in keeping with a most craven Daley loyalist. That the boss is out to tame or break the Chicago Teacher's Union with his "Renaissance 2010" scheme ought to be obvious.
The military and naval recruiting schools are part of the plan.
Smith is also a darling of the real estate developers and has helped them with numerous teardowns of architectually and historically important buildings. Not to mention displacement of working people from the ward.
Re: 500 Stand Up for Senn High School
07 Oct 2004
Over 800 Stand Up for Senn
07 Oct 2004
Re: 500 Stand Up for Senn High School
07 Oct 2004
Re: 500 Stand Up for Senn High School
08 Oct 2004
Enclosed are two eyewitness accounts...long but interesting, about the protest at Senn HS against the proposed military HS.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I went to the Community Forum at Senn High School last night, at which the prposed Naval Academy was to be discussed. The school, for those who haven't visited it, is massive and architecturally unique--one of those lovely old Chicago schools surrounded by lawns and trees, in the middle of an Edgewater neighborhood. Parked out front I noticed a Channel 2 TV van. Inside, the halls were lined with artwork and "science-fair" style displays highlighting aspects of the school and its students--awards won, special programs, great achievements. It was impressive. Even more impressive, though, was the turn- out. The halls were flowing with people moving to the auditorium, where the Forum was to be held. I arrived at about 6:45, just in time to sign in and pick up literature, including a copy of the Senn-Times, that featured a story with this headline--"I was in boot camp prison: Misunderstanding sends Senn grad to Army"--and a sheet listing the "Birthplaces of Our Students (over 70 countries). A preponderance of sectarian groups hung around the entrance to the room (and to the school outside), passing out leaflets and trying to sell papers, and were everywhere in the auditorium as well (for example, Spartacists, and the International Socialist Organization). But the real action was already underway in the auditorium, where students and families nearly filled the seats; there were hundreds in attendance. On a large screen a video flickered, while a cacophony of sounds crackled through the room. Kids were marching with hand-made signs--Save Senn! Keep the military out of our school! Don't suffocate us! At the front of the room a group was talking through a loudspeaker, rotating languages--Spanish, Arabic, English, and more. They were translating the speakers in seven languages for the audience of parents, students, and community members. All of a sudden, the CPS and military folks trying to show the video, which was supposed to highlight the many features of the planned Navy Academy, turned off the tape and marched out of the room as the audience hissed and booed. What I had missed, I found out later, was the audience standing and turning their backs on the video.
A line-up of speakers were called to the mic. The sound-system was awful; it was hard to make out words amidst the static. But spirits were high, and I caught some of what people said. A theme that was expressed several times was the wrongness of foisting a military school on a community of low income "minority" kids, and that CPS shouldn't be in the business of recruiting for the military. Students continued to march; some teachers spoke. Sitting near me was a woman who grew exasperated. She grabbed her child and started to leave, saying, "This was supposed to be for the community, but they aren't taking questions or listening to anyone." But overall the room felt energized, like there was momentum and excitement and the will to stick with the task of opposing the planned Navy Academy. A friend sitting near the front of the room told me that all of those who had fled earlier later slowly trickled back into the room and sat near the speakers taking notes, including who she called "the military arm of the CPS."
I left at 8:00 and things were still going strong. I'd love to hear from anyone who stayed later, about what happened at the end.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Last night B____ and I attended the community meeting at Senn High School regarding the possibility of a naval academy being set up in the south wing of the school. I share with you a few thoughts which I was prepared to share at the meeting and our experience of the meeting.
Our Edgewater neighborhood and Senn High School are incredibly ethnically and culturally diverse. Presently 746 students were born outside the USA, 57 different languages are spoken in the school, and 1111, students, or 64.6% of the student body, speak a language other than English as their home language. (A previous email by a parishioner highlighted a few of Senn's recent accomplishments.) Many of Senn's students and their families have fled from countries where the military represents oppression and violence. Those who favor military academies say that they provide structure, discipline and higher expectations which some teens need in order to do well in school? Do some kids need more structure and discipline in their education? Yes. Do they need to focus, do well, learn and graduate? Of course. Does that mean then that we call in the military to solve these problems? What does that teach our children and say to our neighbors from around the world about how we solve problems? Why can we not impose the needed structure, discipline and expectations without bringing in the military? Why not set a precedent for out city, our nation and our present federal administration and establish a serious peace academy where children, parents and neighbors together can learn and practice the great discipline of non-violence? Where people are trained to be peace ambassadors, mediators and negotiators of every kind of conflict? Where the best in conflict resolution of all that has been offered in various school throughout the city is brought together in one center, one academy of peace? This idea is not novel. What may be lacking is the communal will and resolve.
The following is our experience of the meeting. On entering the auditorium, we felt the energy of the large crowd of both students and neighbors who were present. Many students holding signs indicating their opposition to the CPS plan were scattered about the auditorium. Alderwoman Mary Ann Smith said something about the nature of the meeting and then introduced David Pickens, Deputy to the CEO of Chicago Public Schools, who eventually introduced Colonel Rick Mills, the CEO-type of the Chicago military schools (presently three), who attempted to show a promotional video of the Naval JROTC program. Any time any of the speakers tried to speak either of their intent to give information about the program or of the plan to set up the school much verbal resistance was expressed by people in the crowd. The volume of the crowd combined with the poor sound system made hearing the message quite difficult. Initially, both Brenda and I as well as one of the principals felt a little uncomfortable by the crowd not allowing the speakers to speak. We felt the audience should at least give them a chance to speak in order for us to then respond. One of the principals, the only one who had any success at quieting the crowd, requested that the students be respectful and give the speakers the chance to explain the proposal. After the Deputy to the CEO gave up and handed the microphone to the Colonel who introduced the promotional video, the vocal disapproval grew louder and the crowd little by little all turned their backs to the Colonel. Finally the crowd cheered as the Colonel, his assistant and the Deputy left the auditorium.
After being there a short while, we too joined in the resistance, especially as I began to see the crowd's response in another light. As someone near us said, "What a great education these kids are getting in democracy!" and a great lesson in civil disobedience, I later thought. After the speakers left, a teacher expressed from the microphone what many were feeling from the start of the meeting, that the community had been left out of the discussion and needed to be heard. Then, one-by-one, students, parents, teachers and neighbors approached the microphone and shared their reflections. Though it was still hard to hear, the opposition to the proposal was quite clear.
It would be great to think that because of this one event the Chicago Board of Education will scrap the plan and look elsewhere but I doubt they will give up that easily. The resistance will need to continue and even grow and more people in the community who are opposed will need to let Mary Ann Smith (784-5277), Arne Duncan, CEO of CPS (553-1550) and Mayor Daley (312-744-3300) know of their opposition. If you want to know more about the status of the CPS proposal, go to Senn High School's website against the plan at www.savesenn.org. They are having regular meetings too.
Re: 500 Stand Up for Senn High School
13 Oct 2004
http://penispatch.fastesthost.org
13 Aug 2005
http://maleenhancementvitamins.webnamez.net
13 Aug 2005
http://enlargepenis.findfree.org
13 Aug 2005